| Our 1990 article reported on recent papers in the peer-reviewed literature and
two international symposia, one at the International Agency for Research on
Cancer (2) and the other at Harvard University (3), all concluding that
chrysotile fibers are less active than amphibole types (crocidolite, amosite,
tremolite) of asbestos in the causation of mesothelioma in man. In his summary
of the IARC meeting, Sir Richard Doll, an eminent epidemiologist, concluded
there is the difference between the effects of chrysotile and amphiboles, which
is so great in relation to mesothelioma that it is possible to argue that
chrysotile does not cause mesothelioma at all (2). This observation has been
supported by numerous peer-reviewed papers and working groups subsequently
(4-6). |
| Mr. Bichard finds it hard to contain his anger over his medical problems
and those of colleagues who are dead or are suffering from lung cancer,
brain tumours, or mesothelioma, a rare cancer of the lung lining. |
| Ralls statement that countervailing human data on the carcinogenic effects of
chrysotile asbestos (including large numbers of mesotheliomas among Canadians)
exist is reminiscent of a similar claim by Nicholson et al. (7) in which his
exaggerated numbers were correctly put into perspective by the epidemiologists
studying the Canadian workers (8). His unreferenced conclusion that
mesotheliomas are largely from chrysotile exposure in insulation workers and
family members who were exposed to low doses ignores the fact that these
individuals encountered mixed exposures to chrysotile and amphiboles at much
higher concentrations than levels of asbestos (predominantly chrysotile)
occurring in homes and public buildings today. Moreover, Rall does not
acknowledge the significant content of amphibole fibers in the lungs of these
workers (9) as well as recent studies showing a correlation between the lung
burden of tremolite, but not chrysotile, in the lungs of Canadian miners with
mesothelioma (. |
| Dr. Finkelstein also cited five cases of mesothelioma among former
Holmes workers. Three of the five workers died at less than fifty years
of age and all were less than sixty years old! |
| In order to provide estimates of the accuracy of death certification
of malignant pleural mesothelioma in Italy, the causes of
death of a series of ascertained cases were investigated. The study
included 523 cases of pleural mesothelioma diagnosed in
1984-1988 by 88 hospital departments and clinics. Vital status at 7
May 1990 was ascertained for 92.7% of subjects. The
overall concordance between pathological diagnosis and death
certification was about 75%.
___________________________________________________________
Med Lav 1994 Mar-Apr;85(2):157-60 |
